Free Buyer's Scorecard

Compare the top incentive compensation platforms before you buy

Don't rely on feature checklists or sales demos alone. Use this buyer's guide to evaluate leading ICM solutions against the criteria that have the biggest impact on implementation success, administrator productivity, and long-term scalability.

Built from real enterprise customer experience

Evaluate ICM vendors with a proven framework

This scorecard is built from the same framework used in Performio’s ICM Buyer’s Guide. It applies the ten core decision factors that shape real-world ICM performance including agility, data management, scalability, and support quality—so you can evaluate your vendor shortlist with confidence.

arrow-right-dark-blue

How to use the scorecard



  • Make a copy of the workbook in Excel or Google Sheets.
  • Define your decision criteria.
  • Assign weights to each factor.
  • List your ICM vendor candidates.
  • Score each vendor across all factors to generate a weighted result.
  • Use the results to inform your final vendor decision.

Explore more resources

Report 19 min

Performio Named Strong Performio in The Forrester Wave™ 2025

Download Report
Guide 16 min

How To Choose An ICM Your Comp Admins Will Actually Use

Download Guide
Data Sheet 10 min

How Performio AI Understands Your Compensation Data

Download Data Sheet